By Rick Morris
On last week's FANTASYDRAFTHELP.COM INSIDER program (Wednesdays, 7-9 PM EDT on SportsTalkNetwork.com), we examined the 2008 NFL Draft winners and losers as determined by our Senior Editor Jason Jones. Here's his lists again (and here's the draft listings for
Round 1,
Round 2,
Round 3,
Round 4,
Round 5,
Round 6 and
Round 7):
WINNERS
Kansas City
Pittsburgh
Baltimore
LOSERS
Tennessee
Chicago
Buffalo
Using the alphabet/grade approach, I'm going to offer my own list. I will speak on these during the FDH INSIDER tomorrow night.
A+: none
A: Pittsburgh
A-: Kansas City, New York Giants
B+: Buffalo, Green Bay, New Orleans, Atlanta, Arizona
B: Miami, New York Jets, Cincinnati, Baltimore, Jacksonville, Dallas, Washington, Carolina
B-: New England, Indianapolis, Denver, Philadelphia, Tampa Bay, St. Louis
C+: Minnesota, Detroit
C: Cleveland, Houston, San Diego, Chicago, Seattle, San Francisco
C-: none
D+: Tennessee
D: Oakland
D-: none
F: none
Additionally, as promised on last week's INSIDER, I have the breakdown of how teams scored based purely on collecting players in Jason's Top 200 Overall from our
FREE draft guide (you can still download it). The scoring works like this: 200 points awarded to the team taking the #1 player on Jason's list (Chris Long), 199 points for the #2 player and so on, all the way down to a single point for #200 on the list. Note that Kansas City scored particularly high because they accrued many picks and were able to use quite a few of them on players who were high on Jason's board.
1. Kansas City: 911
2. Arizona: 843
3. Chicago: 746 (those of you listening to the show last week heard Jason's shock when I read him this ranking -- I saved that information to tell him for the first time when we were on the air!)
4. Tampa Bay: 729
5. Philadelphia: 714
6. Baltimore: 694
7. New York Giants: 693
8. Indianapolis: 667
9. Seattle: 654
10. New Orleans: 651
11. Carolina: 647
12. St. Louis: 631
13. Green Bay: 607
14. Detroit: 595
15T. Denver: 592
15T. Atlanta: 592
17. Washington: 584
18. San Francisco: 550
19. New York Jets: 542
20. Pittsburgh: 514
21. Cincinnati: 492
22. Buffalo: 452
23. Dallas: 433
24. Jacksonville: 425
25. Houston: 404
26. Miami: 392
27. New England: 375
28. San Diego: 329
29. Tennessee: 253
30. Cleveland: 229
31. Oakland: 193
32. Minnesota: 89
As an FYI, here's Jason's Top 200 Overall from our draft guide, with the draft destination of each player. Those who were not drafted are marked with "XXXXX" (including those who subsequently signed with another team in free agency.
Name Position School
1 Chris Long DE Virginia ST LOUIS 200
2 Matt Ryan QB Boston College ATLANTA 199
3 Sedrick Ellis DT USC NEW ORLEANS 198
4 Rashard Mendenhall RB Illinois PITTSBURGH 197
5 Jake Long OT Michigan MIAMI 196
6 Vernon Gholston DE Ohio St NEW YORK JETS 195
7 Leodis McKelvin CB Troy BUFFALO 194
8 Darren McFadden RB Arkansas OAKLAND 193
9 Glenn Dorsey DT LSU KANSAS CITY 192
10 Kenny Phillips FS Miami (FL) NEW YORK GIANTS 191
11 Lawrence Jackson DE USC SEATTLE 190
12 Josh Barrett SS Arizona St ARIZONA 189!!!
13 Ryan Clady OT Boise St DENVER 188
14 Jonathan Stewart RB Oregon CAROLINA 187
15 Dominique Rogers-Cromartie CB Tennessee St ARIZONA 186
16 Keith Rivers OLB USC CINCINNATI 185
17 Jeff Otah OT Pittsburgh CAROLINA 184
18 Derrick Harvey DE Florida JACKSONVILLE 183
19 Mike Jenkins CB S. Florida DALLAS 182
20 Branden Albert OG Virginia KANSAS CITY 181
21 Quentin Groves DE Auburn JACKSONVILLE 180
22 Felix Jones RB Arkansas DALLAS 179
23 Reggie Smith CB Oklahoma SAN FRANCISCO 178
24 Brian Brohm QB Louisville GREEN BAY 177
25 Devin Thomas WR Michigan St WASHINGTON 176
26 DeSean Jackson WR California PHILADELPHIA 175
27 Chris Williams OT Vanderbilt CHICAGO 174
28 Kentwan Balmer DT North Carolina SAN FRANCISCO 173
29 Jerod Mayo ILB Tennessee NEW ENGLAND 172
30 Dan Connor ILB Penn St CAROLINA 171
31 Malcolm Kelly WR Oklahoma WASHINGTON 170
32 Dustin Keller TE Purdue NEW YORK JETS 169
33 Calais Campbell DE Miami (FL) ARIZONA 168
34 Aqib Talib CB Kansas TAMPA BAY 167
35 Chad Henne QB Michigan MIAMI 166
36 Jamaal Charles RB Texas KANSAS CITY 165
37 Chilo Rachal OG USC SAN FRANCISCO 164
38 Curtis Lofton ILB Oklahoma ATLANTA 163
39 Erin Henderson ILB Maryland XXXXX
40 Cliff Avril OLB Purdue DETROIT 161
41 Carl Nicks OT Nebraska NEW ORLEANS 160
42 Gosder Cherilus OT Boston College DETROIT 159
43 Limas Sweed WR Texas PITTSBURGH 158
44 Trevor Laws DT Notre Dame PHILADELPHIA 157
45 Antione Cason CB Arizona SAN DIEGO 156
46 Pat Sims DT Auburn CINCINNATI 155
47 Fred Davis TE USC WASHINGTON 154
48 Joe Flacco QB Delaware BALTIMORE 153
49 Ray Rice RB Rutgers BALTIMORE 152
50 Sam Baker OT USC ATLANTA 151
51 Jacob Hester FB/RB LSU SAN DIEGO 150
52 Mario Manningham WR Michigan NEW YORK GIANTS 149
53 Jordy Nelson WR Kansas St GREEN BAY 148
54 Anthony Collins OT Kansas CINCINNATI 147
55 Barry Richardson OG Clemson KANSAS CITY 146
56 Xavier Adibi OLB Virginia Tech HOUSTON 145
57 Philip Wheeler ILB Georgia Tech INDIANAPOLIS 144
58 Roy Schuening OG Oklahoma St ST LOUIS 143
59 Marcus Howard ILB Georgia INDIANAPOLIS 142
60 Kevin Smith RB Central Florida DETROIT 141
61 John Carlson TE Notre Dame SEATTLE 140
62 Owen Schmidt FB W. Virginia SEATTLE 139
63 Tavares Gooden ILB Miami (FL) BALTIMORE 138
64 James Hardy WR Indiana BUFFALO 137
65 John Greco OT Toledo ST LOUIS 136
66 Peyton Hillis FB Arkansas DENVER 135
67 Geno Hayes ILB Florida St TAMPA BAY 134
68 Matt Forte RB Tulane CHICAGO 133
69 Mike Pollak C Arizona St INDIANAPOLIS 132
70 Early Doucet WR LSU ARIZONA 131
71 Phillip Merling DE Clemson MIAMI 130
72 Jonathan Goff ILB Vanderbilt NEW YORK GIANTS 129
73 Shawn Crable OLB Michigan NEW ENGLAND 128
74 Drew Radovich OG USC XXXXX
75 Kellen Davis TE Michigan St CHICAGO 126
76 Beau Bell OLB UNLV CLEVELAND 125
77 Dwight Lowery CB San Jose St NEW YORK JETS 124
78 Tom Zbikowski SS Notre Dame BALTIMORE 123
79 Dre Moore DT Maryland TAMPA BAY 122
80 Chris Ellis DE Virginia Tech BUFFALO 121
81 Mike McGlynn OG Pittsburgh PHILADELPHIA 120
82 Vince Hall ILB Virginia Tech XXXXX
83 Kenny Iwebema DE Iowa ARIZONA 118
84 Jamar Adams SS Michigan XXXXX
85 Tracy Porter CB Indiana NEW ORLEANS 116
86 Wesley Woodyard OLB Kentucky XXXXX
87 Bruce Davis OLB UCLA PITTSBURGH 114
88 Robert Felton OG Arkansas XXXXX
89 Jermichael Finley TE Texas GREEN BAY 112
90 Eric Young OG Tennessee XXXXX
91 Quintin Demps FS UTEP PHILADELPHIA 110
92 Terrell Thomas CB USC NEW YORK GIANTS 109
93 Ali Highsmith OLB LSU XXXXX
94 ***Heath Benedict (deceased) OG Newberry XXXXX
95 Spencer Larson ILB Arizona DENVER 106
96 Charles Godfrey CB Iowa CAROLINA 105
97 Matt Flynn QB LSU GREEN BAY 104
98 Marcus Griffin SS Texas XXXXX
99 Red Bryant DT Texas A&M SEATTLE 102
100 Andre Woodson QB Kentucky NEW YORK GIANTS 101
101 Kirk Barton OT Ohio St CHICAGO 100
102 Ezra Butler DE Nevada XXXXX
103 Craig Steltz SS LSU CHICAGO 98
104 Dominique Barber SS Minnesota HOUSTON 97
105 Dexter Jackson WR Appalachain St TAMPA BAY 96
106 Eddie Royal WR Virginia Tech DENVER 95
107 Chris Johnson RB East Carolina TENNESSEE 94
108 Brad Cottam TE Tennessee KANSAS CITY 93
109 Tyrell Johnson CB Arkansas St XXXXX
110 Adarius Bowman WR Oklahoma St XXXXX
111 Adrian Arrington WR Michigan NEW ORLEANS 90
112 Frank Okam DT Texas HOUSTON 89
113 Jeremy Zuttah C Rutgers TAMPA BAY 88
114 Caleb Campbell SS Army DETROIT 87
115 Mike Hart RB Michigan INDIANAPOLIS 86
116 DeMario Pressley DT N.C. State NEW ORLEANS 85
117 Jacob Tamme TE Kentucky INDIANAPOLIS 84
118 Justin Forsett RB California SEATTLE 83
119 Lavelle Hawkins WR California TENNESSEE 82
120 Donnie Avery WR Houston ST LOUIS 81
121 Ben Moffitt ILB S. Florida XXXXX
122 Brandon Flowers CB Virginia Tech KANSAS CITY 79
123 Allen Patrick RB Oklahoma BALTIMORE 78
124 Jason Jones DE Eastern Michigan TENNESSEE 77
125 John David Booty QB USC MINNESOTA 76
126 Kevin O'Connell QB San Diego St NEW ENGLAND 75
127 Andre Caldwell WR Florida CINCINNATI 74
128 Steve Slaton RB W. Virginia HOUSTON 73
129 Martellus Bennett TE Texas A&M DALLAS 72
130 Justin King CB Penn St ST LOUIS 71
131 Chevis Jackson CB LSU ATLANTA 70
132 Steve Justice C Wake Forest INDIANAPOLIS 69
133 Kory Lichtensteiger C Bowling Green DENVER 68
134 Titus Brown DE Mississippi St XXXXX
135 Patrick Lee CB Auburn GREEN BAY 66
136 David Roach SS TCU XXXXX
137 Wallace Gilberry DE Alabama XXXXX
138 Josh Johnson QB San Diego TAMPA BAY 63
139 Jerome Felton RB Furman DETROIT 62
140 Marcus Monk WR Arkansas CHICAGO 61
141 JoLonn Dunbar ILB Boston College XXXXX
142 Cory Byrd RB S. Carolina TAMPA BAY 59
143 Jonathan Zenon CB LSU XXXXX
144 Shannon Tevaga OG UCLA XXXXX
145 Paul Hubbard WR Wisconsin CLEVELAND 56
146 William Franklin WR Missouri KANSAS CITY 55
147 Erik Ainge QB Tennessee NEW YORK JETS 54
148 Earl Bennett WR Vanderbilt CHICAGO 53
149 Jack Ikegwuonu CB Wisconsin PHILADELPHIA 52
150 Chris Harrington DE Texas A&M ARIZONA 51
151 Oniel Cousins OT UTEP BALTIMORE 50
152 Jameel McClain ILB Syracuse XXXXX
153 Martin Rucker TE Missouri CLEVELAND 48
154 Chad Rinehart OT Univ of N. Iowa WASHINGTON 47
155 Chase Ortiz DE TCU XXXXX
156 Dennis Dixon QB/WR Oregon PITTSBURGH 45
157 Johnny Dingle DT W. Virginia XXXXX
158 Matt Spanos C USC XXXXX
159 Tommy Blake DE TCU XXXXX
160 Joe Jon Finley TE Oklahoma XXXXX
161 BenJarvis Green-Ellis RB Ole Miss XXXXX
162 Ryan O'Hara QB Central Oklahoma XXXXX
163 Jamie Silva SS Boston College XXXXX
164 Colt Brennan QB Hawaii WASHINGTON 37
165 Glenn Sharpe CB Miami (FL) XXXXX
166 Larry Grant LB Ohio St SAN FRANCISCO 35
167 Jonathan Hefney FS Tennessee XXXXX
168 Chauncey Washington RB USC JACKSONVILLE 33
169 Yvenson Bernard RB Oregon St XXXXX
170 Mario Urritia WR Louisville CINCINNATI 31
171 Adam Kraus OG Michigan XXXXX
172 Trae Williams CB S. Florida JACKSONVILLE 29
173 Greyson Gunheim DE Washington XXXXX
174 Sam Keller QB Nebraska XXXXX
175 Dantrell Savage RB Oklahoma St XXXXX
176 DaJuan Morgan RB N.C. State XXXXX
177 D.J. Wolfe CB Oklahoma XXXXX
178 DeJuan Tribble CB Boston College SAN DIEGO 23
179 Kyle Wright QB Miami (FL) XXXXX
180 Rafael Little RB Kentucky XXXXX
181 Doug Legursky OG Marshall XXXXX
182 Kalvin McRae RB Ohio University XXXXX
183 Tyler Polumbus OT Colorado XXXXX
184 De'Cody Fagg WR Florida St XXXXX
185 Pedro Sosa OT Rutgers XXXXX
186 Darius Reynaud WR W. Virginia XXXXX
187 Bryan Kehl ILB BYU NEW YORK GIANTS 14
188 John Sullivan C Notre Dame MINNESOTA 13
189 Franklin Dunbar OT Mid Tennessee St XXXXX
190 Jordan Grimes OG Purdue XXXXX
191 Tom Santi TE Virginia INDIANAPOLIS 10
192 Thomas DeCoud SS California ATLANTA 9
193 Michael Grant S Arkansas XXXXX
194 Gary Guyton ILB Georgia Tech XXXXX
195 Andre Callender RB Boston College XXXXX
196 Kolo Kapanui TE West Texas A&M XXXXX
197 Shannon Boatman OT Florida St XXXXX
198 D.J. Hall WR Alabama XXXXX
199 Taylor Mehlhaff K Wisconsin NEW ORLEANS 2
200 Zach Bowman CB Nebraska CHICAGO 1